Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2024 | MaXXXine (2024) | John Labat |
| 2024 | Beverly Hills Cop: Axel F (2024) | Captain Grant |
| 2023 | Leave the World Behind (2023) | Danny |
| 2023 | The Toxic Avenger Unrated (2025) | Bob Garbinger (The Villain) |
| 2022 | One Way (2022) | A...hole / Fred Sr. |
| 2022 | Space Oddity (2023) | Jeff McAllister |
| 2016 | The Darkness | Peter Taylor |
| 2016 | Patriots Day | Special Agent Richard DesLauriers |
| 2015 | Black Mass | FBI Agent Charles McGuire |
| 2015 | Cop Car | Sheriff Kretzer |
| 2013 | R.I.P.D. | Hayes |
| 2012 | Jayne Mansfield's Car | Carroll Caldwell |
| 2011 | X-Men: First Class | Sebastian Shaw |
| 2011 | Crazy, Stupid, Love | David Lindhagen |
| 2011 | Elephant White | Jimmy The Brit |
| 2010 | Super | Jacques |
| 2009 | New York, I Love You | Tom |
| 2009 | My One and Only | Dan Devereaux |
| 2009 | Taking Chance | Lt. Col. Mike Strobl |
| 2008 | Frost/Nixon | Jack Brennan |
| 2007 | Rails & Ties | Tom Stark |
| 2007 | Death Sentence | Nick Hume |
| 2007 | The Air I Breathe | Love |
| 2005 | Beauty Shop | Jorge Christophe |
| 2005 | Where the Truth Lies | Lanny Morris |
| 2004 | Cavedweller | Randall Pritchard |
| 2004 | The Woodsman | Walter |
| 2004 | Forces of Nature (2004) | Narrator |
| 2003 | Mystic River | Sean Devine |
| 2000 | My Dog Skip | Jack Morris |
| 2000 | We Married Margo | Self |
| 2000 | Hollow Man | Sebastian Caine |
| 1999 | Stir of Echoes | Tom Witzky |
| 1998 | Wild Things | Sgt. Ray Duquette |
| 1996 | Sleepers | Sean Nokes |
| 1995 | Apollo 13 (2002 re-release) | Jack Swigert |
| 1995 | Balto | Balto |
| 1994 | The Air Up There | Jimmy Dolan |
| 1994 | The River Wild (2023) | Wade |
| 1992 | A Few Good Men | Capt. Jack Ross |
| 1991 | JFK | Willie O'Keefe |
| 1991 | He Said, She Said | Dan Hanson |
| 1990 | Tremors (1990) | Valentine McKee |
| 1990 | Flatliners (1990) | David Labraccio |
| 1989 | The Big Picture (1989) | Nick Chapman |
| 1988 | End of the Line | Everett |
| 1988 | She's Having a Baby | Jake Briggs |
| 1987 | Planes, Trains and Automobiles | Taxi Racer |
| 1987 | Lemon Sky | Alan |
| 1986 | Quicksilver | Jack Casey |
| 1984 | Footloose (1984) | Ren McCormack |
| 1982 | Diner (1982) | Timothy Fenwick Jr. |
| 1982 | Forty Duece | Ricky |
| 1980 | Friday the 13th (1980) | Jack Burrell |
| 1978 | Animal House | Chip Diller |
