Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2025 | Train Dreams (2025) | Robert Grainier |
| 2025 | The Plague (2025) | Daddy Wags |
| 2024 | Daughters (2024) | Executive Producer |
| 2024 | I Don't Understand You (2025) | Producer |
| 2023 | The Boys in the Boat (2023) | Al Ulbrickson |
| 2022 | Thirteen Lives (2022) | Dr. Richard Harris |
| 2022 | Master Gardener (2023) | Narvel Roth |
| 2021 | The Green Knight (2021) | The Lord |
| 2019 | The King (2019) | Falstaff |
| 2018 | Red Sparrow | Nate Nash |
| 2018 | Gringo (2018) | Richard Rusk |
| 2018 | Boy Erased | Victor Sykes |
| 2017 | It Comes at Night | Paul |
| 2017 | Bright (2017) | Nick Jakoby |
| 2016 | Jane Got a Gun | Dan Frost |
| 2016 | Midnight Special | Lucas |
| 2016 | Loving | Richard Loving |
| 2015 | Black Mass | John Connolly |
| 2015 | The Gift (2015) | Gordo |
| 2015 | Unity | Narrator |
| 2015 | Life (2015) | John Morris |
| 2014 | Exodus: Gods and Kings | Ramses |
| 2013 | The Great Gatsby (2013) | Tom Buchanan |
| 2013 | Felony | Malcolm Toohey |
| 2012 | The Odd Life of Timothy Green | Jim Green |
| 2012 | Zero Dark Thirty | Patrick |
| 2012 | Wish You Were Here (2013) | Dave Flannery |
| 2011 | Warrior | Brendan |
| 2011 | The Thing (2011) | Carter |
| 2011 | Fighting Fear | Narrator |
| 2010 | Animal Kingdom | Barry 'Baz' Brown |
| 2010 | Legend of the Guardians: The Owls of Ga'Hoole | Metal Beak |
| 2009 | The Waiting City | Ben Simmons |
| 2008 | Acolytes | Ian Wright |
| 2008 | $9.99 | Ron |
| 2008 | The Square (2010) | Billy |
| 2007 | Whisper | Vince Delayo |
| 2007 | Crossbow | The Dad |
| 2006 | Open Window | Peter |
| 2005 | Kinky Boots | Charlie Price |
| 2005 | The Mysterious Geographic Explorations of Jasper Morello | Jasper Morello |
| 2004 | King Arthur (2004) | Gawain |
| 2003 | Ned Kelly | Aaron Sherritt |
| 2003 | The Night We Called It a Day | Rod Blue |
| 2002 | The Hard Word | Shane |
| 2000 | The Three Stooges (2000) | Tom Cosgrove |
| 1999 | Erskineville Kings | Wayne |
| 1998 | Praise | Leo |
