Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2026 | Beast (2026) | Actor, Screenwriter, Writer |
| 2026 | The Get Out (2026) | Marco Kapak |
| 2026 | The Weight (2026) | Actor |
| 2025 | Nuremberg (2025) | Hermann Göring |
| 2024 | Kraven the Hunter (2024) | Nikolai Kravinoff |
| 2024 | Land of Bad (2024) | Reaper |
| 2024 | Sleeping Dogs (2024) | Roy Freeman |
| 2024 | The Exorcism (2024) | Anthony Miller |
| 2024 | Andrea Bocelli 30: The Celebration | Self |
| 2023 | The Pope's Exorcist (2023) | Father Gabriele Amorth |
| 2022 | Thor: Love and Thunder (2022) | Zeus |
| 2022 | The Greatest Beer Run Ever (2022) | Coates |
| 2022 | Poker Face (2022) | Jake |
| 2020 | Unhinged (2020) | Man |
| 2019 | True History of the Kelly Gang | Harry Power |
| 2018 | Boy Erased | Marshall Eamons |
| 2018 | Turtle Odyssey | Narrator |
| 2017 | The Mummy (2017) | Henry Jekyll |
| 2016 | The Nice Guys | Jackson Healy |
| 2015 | Fathers and Daughters | Jake Davis |
| 2014 | Winter's Tale (2014) | Pearly Soames |
| 2014 | Noah (2014) | Noah |
| 2014 | The Water Diviner | Joshua Connor |
| 2013 | Man of Steel | Jor-El |
| 2013 | Broken City | Mayor Hostetler |
| 2013 | Red Obsession | Narrator |
| 2012 | Les Miserables (2012) | Inspector Javert |
| 2012 | The Man With the Iron Fists | Jack Knife |
| 2010 | Robin Hood (2010) | Robin Longstride |
| 2010 | The Next Three Days | John Brennan |
| 2009 | State of Play | Cal McAffrey |
| 2008 | Tenderness | Detective Cristofuoro |
| 2008 | Body of Lies | Ed Hoffman |
| 2007 | American Gangster | Richie Roberts |
| 2007 | Bra Boys | Narrator |
| 2007 | Cowboy Brunch: 3:10 TO YUMA (2007) w/ The Wolf | Ben Wade |
| 2006 | A Good Year | Max Skinner |
| 2005 | Cinderella Man | Jim Braddock |
| 2003 | Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World | Jack "Lucky" Aubrey |
| 2001 | A Beautiful Mind (2001) | John Nash |
| 2000 | Gladiator | Maximus Decimus Meridius |
| 2000 | Proof of Life | Terry Thorne |
| 1999 | The Insider | Jeffrey Wigand |
| 1999 | Mystery, Alaska | John Biebe |
| 1997 | L.A. Confidential | Officer Wendell 'Bud' White |
| 1997 | Breaking Up | Steve |
| 1995 | The Quick And The Dead | Cort |
| 1995 | Rough Magic | Alex Ross |
| 1995 | Virtuosity | SID 6.7 |
| 1994 | The Sum of Us | Jeff Mitchell |
| 1992 | Romper Stomper | Hando |
| 1991 | Proof (1992) | Andy |
