Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2026 | THE BRIDE! (2026) | Jake Wiles |
| 2024 | September 5 (2024) | Roone Arledge |
| 2023 | Memory (2023) | Saul |
| 2023 | Coup! (2024) | Actor |
| 2023 | Pet Shop Days (2023) | Peter Sarsgaard |
| 2022 | The Batman (2022) | District Attorney Gil Colson |
| 2021 | The Guilty (2021) | Henry Fisher |
| 2020 | Best Summer Ever | Executive Producer |
| 2019 | The Sound of Silence | Peter Lucian |
| 2017 | Loving Pablo | Shepard |
| 2016 | The Magnificent Seven (2016) | Bartholomew Bogue |
| 2016 | Jackie | Bobby Kennedy |
| 2015 | Black Mass | Brian Halloran |
| 2015 | Ladygrey | Samuel |
| 2015 | Experimenter | Stanley Milgram |
| 2014 | Valley Uprising | Narrator |
| 2014 | Pawn Sacrifice | William Lombardy |
| 2013 | Lovelace | Chuck Traynor |
| 2013 | Blue Jasmine | Dwight |
| 2013 | Night Moves | Harmon |
| 2013 | Very Good Girls | Joe Fitzsimmons |
| 2012 | Robot & Frank | Robot |
| 2011 | Green Lantern | Hector Hammond |
| 2010 | Knight and Day | Fitzgerald |
| 2009 | Orphan | John |
| 2009 | In the Electric Mist | Elrod Sykes |
| 2009 | An Education | David |
| 2008 | Elegy | Kenneth Kepesh |
| 2008 | The Mysteries of Pittsburgh | Cleveland Arning |
| 2007 | Year of the Dog (2007) | Newt |
| 2007 | Rendition | Alan Smith |
| 2005 | Flightplan | Carson |
| 2005 | Jarhead | Alan Troy |
| 2005 | The Skeleton Key | Luke |
| 2005 | The Dying Gaul | Robert |
| 2004 | Kinsey | Clyde Martin |
| 2004 | Garden State | Mark |
| 2003 | Shattered Glass | Chuck Lane |
| 2002 | The Salton Sea | Jimmy the Finn |
| 2002 | Unconditional Love | Window Washer |
| 2002 | K-19: The Widowmaker | Reactor Officer Vadim Radtchenko |
| 2002 | Empire | Jack Wimmer |
| 2001 | The Center of the World | Richard Longman |
| 2000 | Housebound (2003) | Tom |
| 1999 | Boys Don’t Cry (1999) | John Lotter |
| 1999 | Another Day in Paradise | Ty |
| 1998 | The Man in the Iron Mask | Raoul |
