Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2025 | Jay Kelly (2025) | Timothy |
| 2021 | Die in a Gunfight (2021) | Narrator |
| 2019 | Where'd You Go, Bernadette | Elgie |
| 2019 | After the Wedding (2019) | Oscar |
| 2017 | Alien: Covenant | Oram |
| 2017 | 1 Mile to You | Coach K |
| 2016 | 20th Century Women | William |
| 2016 | Jackie | The Journalist |
| 2016 | Youth in Oregon | Brian Gleason |
| 2015 | The Stanford Prison Experiment | Dr. Philip Zimbardo |
| 2015 | Spotlight | Eric MacLeish |
| 2014 | The Longest Week | Dylan Tate |
| 2014 | Rudderless | Sam |
| 2014 | Glass Chin | J.J. Cook |
| 2013 | Blood Ties | Frank |
| 2013 | Supermensch: The Legend of Shep Gordon | William Miller (archive footage) |
| 2011 | Thin Ice | Randy Kinney |
| 2011 | Too Big to Fail | Timothy Geithner |
| 2010 | Eat Pray Love | Stephen |
| 2009 | Watchmen | Jon Osterman/Dr. Manhattan |
| 2009 | Public Enemies | J. Edgar Hoover |
| 2008 | Pretty Bird | Curtis Prentiss |
| 2007 | Dedication | Henry Roth |
| 2006 | Mission: Impossible III | John Musgrave |
| 2006 | The Good Shepherd | Arch Cummings |
| 2005 | Trust the Man | Tobey |
| 2004 | Stage Beauty | Ned Kynaston |
| 2003 | Big Fish | Will Bloom |
| 2001 | Charlotte Gray | Julien |
| 2001 | World Traveler | Cal |
| 2000 | Almost Famous | Russell Hammond |
| 2000 | Waking The Dead | Fielding Pierce |
| 1999 | Jesus' Son | FH |
| 1998 | Without Limits | Steve Prefontaine |
| 1998 | Monument Ave. | Teddy |
| 1998 | The Hi-Lo Country | Pete Calder |
| 1997 | Princess Mononoke 4K (2025) | Ashitaka |
| 1996 | Sleepers | Tommy Marcano |
| 1996 | Grind (1997) | Eddie Dolan |
