Now that Andrew Garfield has been chosen to play Spider-Man in the Marc Webb-directed 2012 3D reboot, attention now turns to which actress will be chosen to play his love interest in the movie. In a not-so-surprising twist proving the studio may want to try to distance itself a little from the previous franchise for comparison's sake, this time around Mary Jane Watson will not be Peter Parker's main squeeze – at least not for the first installment. Nope, and it isn't clear either whether they will instead focus on the character Gwen Stacy (who did make an appearance in Spider-Man 3; Bryce Dallas Howard played her), or if they'll go all the way back and cast an actress to play another one of Parker's girlfriends, Betty Brant.
Meanwhile, while Spider-Man geeks engage in hardcore debates over which love interest is more appropriate for the reboot, a few actresses have been named as possible contenders. They are: Imogen Poots (Fright Night), Ophelia Lovibond (Nowhere Boy), Lilly Collins (The Blind Side), Teresa Palmer (The Sorcerer's Apprentice), Emma Roberts (Valentine's Day, Hotel for Dogs), and Mary Elizabeth Winstead (Scott Pilgrim vs. the World), though the latter has apparently dropped out of the race, which is too bad because she kills it in Pilgrim.
Keep in mind they could add more to this list if none of these girls work out. Remember the circus surrounding the Spider-Man casting and all the different guys who tried out for that one? Exactly. In the meantime, though, let's have some fun and try to decide which one of these girls would be best alongside Spidey. My pick? I'm a little up in the air, to be honest, though I'm kinda leaning toward Lily Collins only because she has a bit of a quick-witted edge that I'd like to see more of.
Get the Street Fighter Collector's Pack for one movie ticket to Street Fighter, plus an Arcade Machine Tin Popcorn Bucket and a Lenticular Collectible.
*Street Fighter Collector's Pack is non-refundable. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Limited time offer. While supplies last. Movie ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. Popcorn not included. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. The Arcade Machine Tin Popcorn Bucket and a Lenticular Collectible will begin shipping in October. Please use a physical U.S. address where the Arcade Machine Tin Popcorn Bucket and Lenticular Collectible shipment can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. See full terms and conditions at https://store.fandango.com/products/street-fighter-collectors-pack
Get The Knockout Bundle and receive one I Play Rocky movie ticket or one Rocky 50th Anniversary movie ticket, and one Rocky Popcorn Bucket!
*The Knockout Bundle is non-refundable. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Limited time offer. While supplies last. Movie ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. Popcorn not included. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. The Staircase Popcorn Bucket will begin shipping in October. Please use a physical U.S. address where the Staircase Popcorn Bucket shipment can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. See full terms and conditions at https://store.fandango.com/products/the-knockout-bundle
Get the Godzilla Minus Zero Collector's Print Bundle and receive one ticket to Godzilla Minus Zero and a Collectible Print!
*Godzilla Minus Zero Collector's Print Bundle is non-refundable. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Limited time offer. While supplies last. Movie ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. The collectible print will begin shipping in October. Please use a physical U.S. address where the collectible print shipment can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. See full terms and conditions at https://store.fandango.com/products/godzilla-minus-zero-collectors-print-bundle
Get 1 free ticket instantly when you join FanClub with your Godzilla Minus Zero ticket order.
The ‘Godzilla Minus Zero – 1 free ticket FanClub Promotion' offer (the “Offer”) begins 5/6/26 and will run for a limited time. Offer valid for new FanClub members only. To be eligible, you must subscribe to a 1-month paid FanClub membership ($9.99 per month + tax) when purchasing tickets Godzilla Minus Zero on the Fandango website or mobile app, and Offer will be automatically applied at checkout. To redeem the Offer, you must complete checkout while an eligible FanClub membership is in your cart and Offer is applied. Offer valid in the U.S. only (excluding U.S. territories and where prohibited by law); void where prohibited. Adjustments to prior purchases not permitted. Taxes may apply. Offer may only be redeemed once per person. Fandango reserves the right to withdraw or modify this Offer at any time, in its sole discretion, and without notice. Additional terms and conditions apply, including Fandango’s Terms and Policies at www.fandango.com/terms-and-policies.
Get the Whalebucket Bundle and receive one movie ticket to Whalefall, a Whale Popcorn Bucket, plus the first chapter of the bestselling book Whalefall!
*The Whalebucket Bundle is non-refundable. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Limited time offer. While supplies last. Movie ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. Popcorn not included. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. The Whalebucket will begin shipping in October. Please use a physical U.S. address where the Whalefall Popcorn Bucket shipment can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. See full terms and conditions https://redeem.fandango.com/products/the-whalebucket-bundle
Buy a ticket to Clayface and get a 30-Day Free Trial to DC Universe Infinite Ultra!
Limited time offer. Log in to your account on Fandango.com or the Fandango app between 9:00am PT on 10/7/26 and 11:59pm PT on 11/1/26 and purchase at least one (1) ticket to see ‘Clayface’ at a participating Fandango theater. Purchaser will receive a post purchase email containing one (1) DC Universe Infinite Promotional Code (“Code”) that is good for one (1) 30-day free trial to DC Universe Infinite Ultra (“DCUI”) with sign-up for a paid DCUI Ultra Monthly subscription. Code expires, and must be redeemed by, 11:59pm PT on 5/1/27. Code is one-time-use only. Free trial offer may be redeemed only once per person and cannot be combined with any other promotional or free trial offer for DCUI. After the free trial period ends, your paid membership will begin at the then-current rate (currently $12.99/month), plus applicable taxes, unless you cancel before the end of the free trial period, and your subscription will automatically renew at the then-current rate plus applicable taxes on a recurring basis, unless you cancel before the applicable renewal. Subscription fees are non-refundable. To cancel or prevent the automatic renewal of your subscription, log in to your DCUI account, go to Settings and click “Cancel” under the Subscription tab. DCUI is not intended for children. Code has no cash value and is non-transferable. You must have, and be logged into, your Fandango account to receive a Code. Fandango is free to join; you must be 18 years of age or older to create a Fandango account. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. This offer is subject to Fandango's terms and policies, at http://www.fandango.com/terms-and-policies. Redemption of the Code and DCUI subscription are subject to DC Universe Infinite’s Terms of Service, at https://www.dcuniverseinfinite.com/terms.