Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2025 | 1780 | Actor |
| 2024 | Peter Five Eight (2024) | Peter |
| 2018 | Billionaire Boys Club (2018) | Ron Levin |
| 2017 | Baby Driver | Doc |
| 2017 | Rebel in the Rye | Whit Burnett |
| 2016 | Nine Lives | Tom Brand |
| 2016 | Elvis & Nixon | Nixon |
| 2015 | Unity | Narrator |
| 2014 | Horrible Bosses 2 | Dave Harken |
| 2014 | NOW: In the Wings on a World Stage | Actor, Executive Producer |
| 2013 | Captain Phillips | Executive Producer |
| 2012 | Safe | Executive Producer |
| 2011 | Horrible Bosses | Dave Harken |
| 2011 | Margin Call | Sam Rogers |
| 2011 | Shakespeare High | Executive Producer |
| 2011 | Inseparable | Chuck |
| 2010 | WWE TLC: Tables, Ladders and Chairs | Director |
| 2010 | The Social Network | Executive Producer |
| 2010 | Casino Jack | Jack Abramoff |
| 2010 | Father of Invention | Robert Axle |
| 2009 | Fanboys | Producer |
| 2009 | The Men Who Stare at Goats | Larry Hooper |
| 2009 | Moon | Gerty |
| 2009 | Shrink | Dr. Henry Carter |
| 2008 | 21 | Micky Rosa |
| 2008 | The Legendary Joe Meek | Major Banks |
| 2008 | Recount | Ron Klain |
| 2007 | The Sasquatch Dumpling Game | Producer |
| 2007 | Fred Claus | Clyde |
| 2006 | Mini's First Time | Producer |
| 2006 | Superman Returns | Lex Luthor |
| 2004 | Beyond the Sea | Bobby Darin |
| 2003 | The Life of David Gale | David Gale |
| 2003 | The United States of Leland | Albert T. Fitzgerald |
| 2001 | K-PAX | Prot |
| 2001 | The Shipping News | Quoyle |
| 2001 | Shackleton's Antarctic Adventure | Narrator |
| 2000 | Pay It Forward | Eugene Simonet |
| 1999 | American Beauty (1999) | Lester Burnham |
| 1999 | The Big Kahuna (1999) | Larry Mann |
| 1999 | Forever Hollywood (1999) | Self |
| 1998 | The Negotiator | Lt. Chris Sabian |
| 1998 | Hurlyburly | Mickey |
| 1998 | A Bug's Life | Hopper |
| 1997 | L.A. Confidential | Jack Vincennes |
| 1997 | Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil | Jim Williams |
| 1996 | Looking for Richard | Buckingham/Himself |
| 1996 | Albino Alligator | Director |
| 1996 | A Time to Kill | D.A. Rufus Buckley |
| 1995 | The Usual Suspects | Roger 'Verbal' Kint |
| 1995 | Se7en | John Doe |
| 1995 | Outbreak (1995) | Maj. Casey Schuler |
| 1994 | The Ref | Lloyd Chasseur |
| 1994 | Swimming With Sharks | Buddy Ackerman |
| 1994 | Iron Will | Harry Kingsley |
| 1992 | Glengarry Glen Ross | John Williamson |
| 1990 | Fall from Grace | Jim Bakker |
| 1990 | Henry & June | Richard Osborn |
| 1989 | See No Evil, Hear No Evil | Kirgo |
| 1988 | Working Girl (Adult) | Bob Speck |
| 1988 | The Murder of Mary Phagan | Wes Brent |
| 1986 | Heartburn | Subway Thief |
