Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2025 | The Fantastic Four: First Steps (2025) | Actor |
| 2025 | Opus (2025) | Moretti |
| 2023 | One Ranger (2023) | Actor, Executive Producer |
| 2023 | Fool's Paradise (2023) | Actor |
| 2023 | Mr. Blake At Your Service (2025) | Andrew Blake |
| 2023 | The Line (2024) | Actor |
| 2022 | Shattered (2022) | Ronald |
| 2022 | Chariot (2022) | Dr. Karn |
| 2022 | White Elephant (2022) | Glen Follett |
| 2022 | Savage Salvation (2022) | Peter |
| 2022 | Mindcage (2022) | The Artist |
| 2021 | Rogue Hostage (2021) | Sam Nelson |
| 2021 | The Survivalist (2021) | Aaron |
| 2020 | Arkansas (2020) | Bright |
| 2019 | Velvet Buzzsaw | Piers |
| 2019 | Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile | Judge Edward D. Cowart |
| 2018 | Supercon | Sid Newberry |
| 2018 | Mile 22 | Bishop |
| 2018 | Casanova Gene | Actor |
| 2018 | Bird Box | Douglas |
| 2017 | Unlocked | Bob Hunter |
| 2017 | The Wilde Wedding | Laurence |
| 2017 | I Love You, Daddy | Leslie |
| 2017 | Bullet Head | Walker |
| 2016 | Deepwater Horizon | Donald Vidrine |
| 2015 | Demolition | Executive Producer |
| 2014 | Cesar Chavez | Bogdanovitch |
| 2014 | Penguins of Madagascar | Dr. Octavius Brine/Dave |
| 2014 | Cut Bank | Sheriff Vogel |
| 2014 | Casanova Variations | Giacomo |
| 2013 | Warm Bodies | Gen. Grigio |
| 2013 | RED 2 | Marvin |
| 2012 | The Perks of Being a Wallflower | Producer |
| 2012 | Lines of Wellington | General Wellington |
| 2011 | Transformers: Dark of the Moon | Bruce Brazos |
| 2011 | Young Adult | Executive Producer |
| 2010 | Jonah Hex | Quentin Turnbull |
| 2010 | Secretariat | Lucien Laurin |
| 2010 | Red (2010) | Marvin Boggs |
| 2010 | Drunkboat | Mort |
| 2009 | Which Way Home | Executive Producer |
| 2008 | Changeling | Rev. Gustav Briegleb |
| 2008 | Afterwards | Garrett Goodrich |
| 2008 | The Great Buck Howard | Buck Howard |
| 2008 | Burn After Reading | Osborne Cox |
| 2008 | Mutant Chronicles | Constantine |
| 2008 | Bloody Mondays & Strawberry Pies | Narrator |
| 2008 | Disgrace | David Lurie |
| 2007 | Beowulf | Unferth |
| 2007 | Juno | Producer |
| 2007 | Gardens of the Night | Michael |
| 2006 | Art School Confidential | Professor Sandford |
| 2006 | Eragon | King Galbatorix |
| 2006 | Klimt | Actor |
| 2005 | The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy | Humma Kavula |
| 2005 | The Libertine | King Charles II |
| 2005 | Color Me Kubrick | Alan Conway |
| 2003 | Johnny English (2003) | Pascal Sauvage |
| 2003 | Kill the Poor | Producer |
| 2003 | A Talking Picture | Comandante John Walesa |
| 2002 | Ripley's Game | Tom Ripley |
| 2002 | How to Draw a Bunny | Executive Producer |
| 2002 | The Dancer Upstairs | Director, Producer |
| 2001 | Ghost World | Producer |
| 2001 | Knockaround Guys | Teddy Deserve |
| 2001 | I'm Going Home | John Crawford |
| 2000 | Shadow of the Vampire | F.W. Murnau |
| 1999 | Being John Malkovich (1999) | John Horatio Malkovich |
| 1999 | The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc | Charles VII |
| 1999 | Time Regained | Le Baron de Charlus |
| 1999 | Ladies Room | Roberto |
| 1998 | Rounders | Teddy KGB |
| 1998 | The Man in the Iron Mask | Athos |
| 1997 | Con Air | Cyrus 'The Virus' Grissom |
| 1996 | Mulholland Falls | General Thomas Timms |
| 1996 | The Portrait of a Lady | Gilbert Osmond |
| 1995 | Beyond the Clouds (1995) | Regista |
| 1994 | Heart of Darkness | Kurtz |
| 1993 | In the Line of Fire | Mitch Leary |
| 1992 | Of Mice and Men (1992) | Lennie Small |
| 1992 | Shadows and Fog | Clown |
| 1991 | The Object of Beauty | Jake |
| 1990 | The Sheltering Sky | Port Moresby |
| 1988 | Miles from Home | Barry Maxwell |
| 1988 | Dangerous Liaisons (1988) | Vicomte Sébastien de Valmont |
| 1987 | Empire of the Sun | Basie |
| 1987 | The Glass Menagerie | Tom Wingfield |
| 1987 | Weird Wednesday: Making Mr. Right | Dr.Jeff Peters/Ulysses |
| 1984 | Places in the Heart | Mr. Will |
| 1984 | The Killing Fields | Alan "Al" Rockoff |
