Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2023 | Fast Charlie (2023) | Stan Mullen |
| 2022 | King on Screen (2023) | Self |
| 2021 | Queen Bees (2021) | Dan |
| 2018 | Out of Blue | Col. Tom Rockwell |
| 2016 | JL Ranch | Tap Peterson |
| 2016 | The Good Neighbor (2016) | Harold Grainey |
| 2016 | Undercover Grandpa | Lou Crawford |
| 2015 | Wuthering High | Earnshaw |
| 2015 | Sicilian Vampire | Professor Bernard Issaacs |
| 2014 | The Outsider (2014) | Karl Schuster |
| 2014 | A Fighting Man | Actor |
| 2014 | Altman | Self |
| 2014 | Preggoland | Walter |
| 2013 | Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2 | Tim Lockwood |
| 2013 | Blood Ties | Leon |
| 2013 | The Tale of the Princess Kaguya - Studio Ghibli Fest 2024 | The Bamboo Cutter |
| 2012 | Small Apartments | Mr. Allspice |
| 2012 | For the Love of Money (2012) | Micky |
| 2011 | Detachment | Mr. Seaboldt |
| 2010 | Henry's Crime | Max |
| 2009 | Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs | Tim Lockwood |
| 2009 | New York, I Love You | Mr. Riccoli |
| 2009 | Hugh Hefner: Playboy, Activist and Rebel | Actor |
| 2009 | Middle Men | Jerry Haggerty |
| 2008 | Get Smart | The President |
| 2003 | Dogville | The Big Man |
| 2003 | Elf | Walter |
| 2003 | Dallas 362 | Walter |
| 2002 | City of Ghosts (2003) | Marvin |
| 2002 | Night at the Golden Eagle | Prison Warden |
| 2002 | This Thing of Ours | Jimmy 'the con' |
| 2000 | The Way of the Gun | Sarno |
| 2000 | The Yards | Frank Olchin |
| 1998 | This Is My Father | Kieran Johnson |
| 1996 | Bottle Rocket (1996) | Abe Henry (Mr. Henry) |
| 1996 | Grand Nord | Sean McLennon |
| 1996 | Bulletproof | Frank Colton |
| 1996 | Eraser | Robert Deguerin |
| 1993 | Flesh and Bone | Roy Sweeney |
| 1992 | Honeymoon in Vegas | Tommy Korman |
| 1991 | For the Boys | Eddie Sparks |
| 1991 | The Dark Backward | Dr. Scurvy |
| 1990 | Misery | Paul Sheldon |
| 1988 | Alien Nation | Det. Sgt. Matthew Sykes |
| 1981 | Thief (1981) | Frank |
| 1981 | Les Uns et les autres | Jack Glenn/Jason Glenn |
| 1980 | Hide in Plain Sight | Thomas Hacklin |
| 1977 | A Bridge Too Far | Staff Sergeant Dohun |
| 1976 | Silent Movie | Self |
| 1976 | Harry and Walter Go To New York/Cinderella Liberty | Harry Dighby |
| 1975 | Funny Lady | Billy Rose |
| 1975 | The Killer Elite (1975) | Mike Locken |
| 1975 | Gone With the West | Jud McGraw |
| 1974 | Freebie and the Bean | Freebie |
| 1974 | The Gambler (1974) | Axel Freed |
| 1973 | Cinderella Liberty | John Baggs Jr. |
| 1972 | The Godfather | Santino "Sonny" Corleone |
| 1971 | Brian's Song | Brian Piccolo |
| 1969 | The Rain People | "Killer" Kilgannon |
| 1967 | Games | Paul Montgomery |
| 1966 | El Dorado (1967) | Mississippi |
| 1965 | Red Line 7000 | Mike |
| 1964 | Lady in a Cage | Randall Simpson O'Connell |
