Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2026 | THE BRIDE! (2026) | Ronnie Reed |
| 2026 | In the Grey (2026) | Bronco |
| 2023 | Guy Ritchie's The Covenant (2023) | Sergeant John Kinley |
| 2022 | Ambulance (2022) | Danny Sharp |
| 2022 | Strange World (2022) | Searcher Clade |
| 2021 | Spirit Untamed (2021) | Jim Prescott |
| 2021 | Breaking News in Yuba County | Producer |
| 2021 | The Guilty (2021) | Joe Baylor |
| 2020 | Relic (2020) | Producer |
| 2020 | The Devil All The Time | Producer |
| 2019 | Spider-Man: Far From Home (2019) | Quentin Beck/Mysterio |
| 2019 | Velvet Buzzsaw | Morf Vandewalt |
| 2018 | Wildlife (2018) | Jerry Brinson |
| 2018 | The Sisters Brothers | John Morris |
| 2017 | Life (2017) | David Jordan |
| 2017 | Okja | Dr. Johnny Wilcox |
| 2017 | Stronger | Jeff Bauman |
| 2017 | Hondros | Executive Producer |
| 2016 | Nocturnal Animals | Tony Hastings/Edward Sheffield |
| 2015 | Southpaw | Billy Hope |
| 2015 | Everest (2015) | Scott Fischer |
| 2015 | Accidental Love | Howard Birdwell |
| 2015 | Demolition | Davis Mitchell |
| 2014 | Nightcrawler | Louis Bloom |
| 2013 | Prisoners | Det. Loki |
| 2013 | Enemy (2014) | Adam Bell/Anthony St. Claire |
| 2012 | End of Watch | Brian Taylor |
| 2011 | Source Code | Colter Stevens |
| 2010 | Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time | Dastan |
| 2010 | Love and Other Drugs | Jamie Randall |
| 2007 | Zodiac | Robert Graysmith |
| 2007 | Rendition | Douglas Freeman |
| 2005 | Proof | Hal |
| 2005 | Jarhead | Anthony Swofford |
| 2005 | Brokeback Mountain: 20th Anniversary (2025) | Jack Twist |
| 2004 | The Day After Tomorrow | Sam Hall |
| 2004 | Jiminy Glick in Lalawood | Self |
| 2002 | Moonlight Mile | Joe Nast |
| 2002 | The Good Girl | Holden Worther |
| 2001 | Bubble Boy | Jimmy Livingston |
| 2001 | Lovely & Amazing | Jordan |
| 2001 | Donnie Darko (2001) | Donnie Darko |
| 1999 | October Sky | Homer Hickam |
