Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2024 | Laws of Man (2025) | Actor |
| 2022 | The Baker (2022) | Merchant |
| 2021 | Lansky (2021) | Meyer Lansky |
| 2020 | Fatima (2020) | Professor Nichols |
| 2019 | The Irishman (2019) | Angelo Bruno |
| 2019 | See You Soon (2019) | Billy |
| 2019 | The Painted Bird | Priest |
| 2018 | Neary's: The Dream at the End of the Rainbow | Noe |
| 2018 | Isle of Dogs | Gondo |
| 2018 | First We Take Brooklyn | Anatoly |
| 2017 | Lies We Tell | Demi |
| 2017 | Madame (2018) | Bob Fredericks |
| 2016 | The Comedian | Mac |
| 2016 | Chosen (2017) | Sonson |
| 2015 | Behind the White Glasses | Self |
| 2015 | The Early Years | Mick Boyle |
| 2014 | The Grand Budapest Hotel | Ludwig |
| 2014 | By the Gun | Salvatore Vitaglia |
| 2014 | Two Men in Town | Bill Agati |
| 2014 | Rio, I Love You | O Ator |
| 2013 | The Congress | Al |
| 2013 | A Farewell to Fools | Father Johanis |
| 2010 | Little Fockers | Randy Weir |
| 2010 | The Last Godfather | Don Carini |
| 2010 | A Beginner's Guide to Endings | Duke White |
| 2009 | The Ministers | Joseph Bruno |
| 2009 | Wrong Turn at Tahoe | Nino |
| 2007 | My Sexiest Year | Zowie |
| 2007 | National Treasure 2 | Peter Sadusky |
| 2006 | A Crime | Roger Culkin |
| 2006 | One Last Dance | Terrtano |
| 2005 | Be Cool | Nicki Carr |
| 2004 | National Treasure (2004) | Sadusky |
| 2004 | The Bridge of San Luis Rey | Uncle Pio |
| 2003 | Crime Spree | Frankie Zammeti |
| 2003 | Galindez File | Robards |
| 2002 | Red Dragon | Jack Crawford |
| 2001 | The Grey Zone | Muhsfeldt |
| 2001 | Mother Viper | Leone |
| 2001 | Taking Sides | Major Steve Arnold |
| 2000 | U-571 | Chief Klough |
| 2000 | Little Nicky | Dad |
| 1999 | Holy Smoke | PJ Walters |
| 1999 | Prince of Central Park | The Guardian |
| 1999 | Three Seasons | James Hager |
| 1998 | Lulu on the Bridge | Izzy Maurer |
| 1997 | Cop Land | Ray Donlan |
| 1997 | Fairy Tale: A True Story | Harry Houdini |
| 1996 | From Dusk Till Dawn | Jacob Fuller |
| 1995 | Get Shorty | Self |
| 1995 | Smoke | Augustus 'Auggie' Wren |
| 1995 | Ulysses' Gaze | A |
| 1995 | Blue in the Face | Auggie Wren |
| 1995 | Clockers | Det. Rocco Klein |
| 1994 | Pulp Fiction | Winston Wolf |
| 1994 | Somebody to Love | Harry Harrelson |
| 1994 | Monkey Trouble | Azro |
| 1994 | Imaginary Crimes | Ray Weiler |
| 1993 | The Piano | George Baines |
| 1993 | Dangerous Game (1993) | Eddie Israel |
| 1993 | Rising Sun | Lt. Tom Graham |
| 1993 | The Young Americans | John Harris |
| 1993 | Point of No Return (1993) | Victor |
| 1992 | Reservoir Dogs | Mr. White/Larry |
| 1992 | Sister Act | Vince LaRocca |
| 1992 | Bad Lieutenant | The Lieutenant |
| 1991 | Bugsy | Mickey Cohen |
| 1991 | Thelma & Louise | Hal |
| 1991 | Mortal Thoughts | Detective John Woods |
| 1990 | The Two Jakes | Julius 'Jake' Berman |
| 1990 | Two Evil Eyes | Roderick Usher (segment "The Black Cat") |
| 1988 | Film Club: The Last Temptation of Christ | Judas Iscariot |
| 1987 | The Pick-Up Artist | Alonzo Scolara |
| 1984 | Cop Killers | Lt. Fred O'Connor |
| 1983 | Exposed (1983) | Rivas |
| 1980 | Bad Timing | Inspector Netusil |
| 1980 | La Mort en direct | Roddy |
| 1979 | Eagle's Wing | Henry |
| 1978 | Blue Collar | Jerry Bartowski |
| 1978 | Fingers | Jimmy Fingers |
| 1977 | Welcome to L.A. | Ken Hood |
| 1977 | The Duellists | Feraud |
| 1976 | Taxi Driver (1976) | Sport |
| 1976 | Buffalo Bill and the Indians | Ed Goodman |
| 1976 | Mother, Jugs & Speed | Speed |
| 1975 | That's the Way of the World | Coleman Buckmaster |
| 1974 | Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore | Ben |
| 1973 | Mean Streets | Charlie |
| 1968 | Who's That Knocking at My Door? | J.R. |
