From 1999's American Pie to the upcoming American Reunion, the group of friends have clearly aged a bit, but still not grown up all the way. Take a look at some character comparisons between then and now.
American Pie - Then and Now
Jason Biggs as Jim Levinstein
Then: High school virgin who had an unfortunate sexual incident with an apple pie.
Now: Married to high school sweetheart Michelle Flaherty with a baby. But probably still experimenting with pies.
American Pie - Then and Now
Alyson Hannigan as Michelle Flaherty
Then: Sweet-looking, but not so innocent girl who had some fun at band camp with her flute.
Now: Married to Jim but still having fun, this time in a bathtub with the portable shower head.
American Pie - Then and Now
Chris Klein as Oz
Then: High school lacrosse jock who joins the choir to impress and finally win the heart of Heather.
Now: Shows up to the reunion with new girlfriend Mia, but might still harbor some feelings for Heather.
American Pie - Then and Now
Mena Suvari as Heather
Then: Uptight, prissy choir girl who ends up falling for Oz and having a very memorable night with him after the prom.
Now: Shows up to the reunion with new boyfriend, cardiac surgeon, Dr. Ron, but might still harbor some feelings for Oz.
American Pie - Then and Now
Seann William Scott as Steve Stifler
Then: Always the party guy out looking for a good time with the ladies!
Now: Same.
American Pie - Then and Now
Eddie Kaye Thomas as Finch
Then: Innocent looking dork who put the moves on Stifler's Mom.
Now: Looks like a bad boy on a motorcycle.
American Pie - Then and Now
Thomas Ian Nicholas as Kevin
Then: Used to date Vicky in high school and shared his first time with her before they broke up after prom.
Now: Has a wife and a beard.
American Pie - Then and Now
Tara Reid as Vicky
Then: Used to date Kevin in high school and shared her first time with him before they broke up after prom.
Now: Still looks hot as ever.
American Pie - Then and Now
Shannon Elizabeth as Nadia
Then: Foreign exchange student who gets topless with Jim and makes him prematurely, uh, become too excited for his own good -- live over a webcam.
Now: Not sure, but maybe she'll repeat what she did from the first film.
American Pie - Then and Now
Eugene Levy as Jim's Dad
Then: A bit conservative and uptight when walking in on his son and an apple pie.
Now: Now single, loosens up at a party with the guys getting drunk and most likely, ends up with Stifler's Mom.
American Pie - Then and Now
Jennifer Coolidge as Stifler's Mom
Then: Sexy seductress who sleeps with Finch.
Now: Sexy seductress who (most likely) sleeps with Jim's Dad.
American Pie - Then and Now
And finally, here is the "Then" poster from 1999's American Pie and this year's "Now" poster from American Reunion. Who's looking all that? You decide.
Got a favorite character from the series? Leave a comment below and let us know.
Special Offer
For one week only, get your ticket to Disney's Tron: Ares and a Limited Edition Topps NOW® Trading Card for $29.99.
*Worlds Will Collide Collector’s Bundle is non-refundable. While supplies last. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Movie ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. The Topps NOW® Trading Card will begin shipping in the month of October. Please use a physical address where the item can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. See full terms and conditions at https://redeem.fandango.com/products/worlds-will-collide-collectors-bundle.
Buy a ticket to Gabby's Dollhouse: The Movie for a chance to win a Meow-Tech Interactive Set including a Gabby's Dollhouse, Ears, and Pandy Plush, and a digital game code for the Gabby's Dollhouse: Ready to Party game on PlayStation, Xbox, or PC.
NO PURCHASE OR APP NECESSARY. Purchase does not increase chances of winning. Open to legal residents of the 50 United States and D.C., 18 years of age and older. Void where prohibited. Ends October 5, 2025, visit https://www.fandangomovietickets.com/gabbysdollhousethemoviesweeps Sponsor: Fandango Media, LLC, 10 Universal City Plaza, Universal City, CA 91608.
Get the Beneath the Surface Bundle for a movie ticket to see JAWS return to the big screen, plus an exclusive limited-edition poster.
*Beneath the Surface Bundle is non-refundable. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Limited time offer. While supplies last. Movie ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice.You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. Poster will ship in August. Please use a physical U.S. address where the poster shipment can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. See full terms and conditions at https://redeem.fandango.com/products/beneath-the-surface-bundle
Get the Friendship & Beyond Poster Bundle and receive a Toy Story 30th Anniversary re-release ticket, an exclusive numbered print, plus 15% off a zoetrope vinyl
*Friendship & Beyond Poster Bundle is non-refundable. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Limited time offer. While supplies last. Movie ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. Please use a physical U.S. address where the poster shipment can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. See full terms and conditions at https://redeem.fandango.com/products/friendship-beyond-poster-bundle.
Buy a ticket to Spinal Tap II: The End Continues, get This is Spinal Tap for $5 on Fandango at Home!
Limited time offer. Log into your account on Fandango.com or the Fandango app and purchase, between 8:00am PT on 8/19/25 and 11:59pm PT on 9/15/25, at least one movie ticket to ‘Spinal Tap II: The End Continues’. Purchaser will receive a post-purchase email containing 1 Fandango at Home Promotional Code (“Code”) that is good for the purchase (and not the rental) of 'This is Spinal Tap' for $5 in My Offers in your account on http://fandangoathome.com and via participating Fandango at Home apps. You must have, and be logged into, your Fandango account to receive a Code. Fandango is free to join; you must be 18 years of age or older to create a Fandango account. Code expires on (and must be used by) 9/17/25 at 11:59pm PT. Limit one per transaction. You may have to pay taxes additionally. One-time use only. Void where prohibited. If lost or stolen, cannot be replaced. Offer is non-transferable and cannot be combined with any other offer or discount. No cash value, except as required by law. Not for resale; void if sold or exchanged. Offer valid in the U.S. only (excluding U.S. territories and where prohibited by law). You must have a Fandango at Home account to redeem your Code on Fandango at Home. Fandango at Home is free to join; you must be 18 years of age or older to open a Fandango at Home account. Credit card may be required for transactions on fandangoathome.com. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. This offer and redemption of the Code are subject to Fandango Terms and Policies and Privacy Policy at http://www.fandango.com/terms-and-policies.
Buy a ticket to The Long Walk, get $10 off the King of Horror: 7 Stephen King Movies bundle on Fandango at Home.
Limited time offer. Log into your account on Fandango.com or the Fandango app between 12:00am ET on 8/27/25 and 11:59pm PT on 10/2/25 and purchase at least one movie ticket to The Long Walk. Purchaser will receive a post purchase email containing 1 Fandango at Home Promotional Code (“Code”) that is good for $10 off the purchase (and not the rental) of the “King of Horror: 7 Stephen King Movies” bundle in My Offers in your account on http://fandangoathome.com and via participating Fandango at Home apps. You must have, and be logged into, your Fandango account to receive a Code. Fandango is free to join; you must be 18 years of age or older to create a Fandango account. Code expires on (and must be used by) 10/5/25 at 11:59pm PT. Limit one per transaction. You may have to pay taxes additionally. One-time use only. Void where prohibited. Offer is non-transferable and cannot be combined with any other offer or discount. No cash value, except as required by law. Not for resale; void if sold or exchanged. Offer valid in the U.S. only. You must have a Fandango at Home account to redeem your Code on Fandango at Home. Fandango at Home is free to join; you must be 18 years of age or older to open a Fandango at Home account. Credit card may be required for transactions on fandangoathome.com. Fandango at Home reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. This offer is subject to Fandango’s Terms and Policies and Privacy Policy at Terms and Policies at http://www.fandango.com/terms-and-policies.
Commemorate one final night at Downton with The Grand Finale Bundle including a Movie Ticket and Limited-Edition Top Hat Popcorn Bucket keepsake.
*The Grand Finale Bundle is non-refundable. While supplies last; Limited time offer. This offer is redeemable for one Downton Abbey: The Grand Finale Bundle (“Bundle”). Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Movie Ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Popcorn not included. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a Bundle. The popcorn bucket will begin shipping in the month of September. Please use a physical address where the item can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. Valid only in the U.S. and D.C., excluding U.S. territories and where prohibited by law. Not valid with any other offer. Limit one (1) Bundle per person. See full terms and conditions at https://redeem.fandango.com/products/the-grand-finale-bundle.