Critics Say


For Parents



By opera woman
Written November 30, 2014
The Opera, live in HD from the Met in New York presented GLORIOUS singing and wonderful acting. We have seen this opera before but this was a much different production. Though I like this one I must say I prefer the old one. Natalie Dessay was lovely and her singing was above reproach in all ways. But what was not good at all was that we had to stand in line outside for over a half hour just waiting for the theater to open. (We had our tickets as did everyone in line) Then we had to wait again inside waiting for them to ready the theater where the opera would be showing. We could see NO reason for this and feel the theater should not have done this at all. It was a very large group of people waiting fortunately in an orderly fashion but quite disgruntled as well they should have been..Many of those waiting were elderly with walkers and canes. We will not go to this theater again. There are plenty of other theaters from which to choose.
16 out of 27 found this helpful. Did you?


By minnag
Written November 28, 2014
I have seen many operas, but this was, by far, the best I have ever seen. I loved it! Natalie Desay was perfect in the role of Violettta,, as were the two other stars in their roles. The main cast is small ,but hold the entire opera. Their voices were at the r best. there was no need for costuming or sets. Their voices were all they needed.
16 out of 26 found this helpful. Did you?

Not so great

By suziesilverado
Written September 16, 2014
I don't like the Metropolitan Opera's stark staging in this production. Also, the sound was not properly balanced in our theater during the first act (this improved later on). During the intermission Natalie Dessai admitted that she missed some of the high notes and Polenzani said that he preferred other roles to that of Alfredo. A strange thing to tell an audience in the middle of a show, even if it's true. But the singing got stronger and the acting was captivating. Hvorostovski was wonderful. And the Met still outshines most other American opera companies.
16 out of 21 found this helpful. Did you?

La Traviata

By marvaleo
Written December 20, 2014
When I saw the set, I thought "On No - not another minimalist update..." The setting and the updates actually enhanced the presentation - more emotion, less schmaltz. Excellent!!!!!!
15 out of 26 found this helpful. Did you?

La Traviata - Outstanding - Best I've Seen

By rjbollinger87
Written April 15, 2012
This is a superb production of one of my favorites. Simply do not have a negative thing to say. So good, would be an excellent show to introduce new potential opera fans to.
14 out of 22 found this helpful. Did you?