Written September 22, 2012
My wife and I Walked out of this film. Totally wasted our evening and money! I guess the only plus was that I guess the film did a good job at protraying what a nut-job this guy was. What was Amy Adams thinking getting involved in such a sick and depraved film. I'm sure there are going to be tons of people who will say they liked it but if you are an intelligent and normal person I wouldn't waste my time....it's disturbing that there are people walking around that would actually enjoy this film and see "beauty" in it. Ugh!!!!
Written September 23, 2012
The master was masterful at putting me to sleep. Acting was very good, but the story was hard to follow, even knowing what the story was supposedly about. Maybe i'm just dumb?
Written October 01, 2012
Joaquin Phoenix and Philip Seymour Hoffman are brilliant, but that is the only reason to see it. The director jumps from one scene to another, scenes are not connected, and the story is ridiculous. I guess you have to really LOVE this director in order to like this so-called ART movie. My husband and myself, and the people in front of us were all looking at our watches. It was close to torture after about the first hour.
Written September 30, 2012
Maybe because there was a problem with the beginning of the movie. We lost a few minutes of it so when it picked up again it was hard to figure out how he got to the hospital. I know that it was supposed to be based on a real story but, I don't remember it. I feel that it was a bit confusing with the jumping back and forth. While the acting was good the story wasn't. I wouldn't tell anyone to go and see it.
Written October 06, 2012
While this is not a mainstream movie for everyone, it was intriguing and fascinating. Phillip Seymour Hoffman and Joaquin Phoenix are assured of best actor nominations. This was a master-class in acting, for sure.
The story concept was interesting, but the characters so unusual, it was hard to tell what they would do. If you want to see the best American actors around, go see this movie. And, go to dinner with friends afterwards. It will stimulate lively discussion.