Written May 13, 2013
I was really surprised at how mediocre this movie was - I'd say the only good part about it was Leo. The cast was just TERRIBLE. Toby Maguire needs to just stop acting...if I had to narrow down what made the movie fail it would be him. His voice is just TERRIBLE as the narrator, and his acting was just as bad. Carey Mulligan did a decent job at acting but she's just not attractive at all so both basically cancelled each other out. The movie was very long and could have been cut short or if they wanted to keep it that long it could have been filled with more meaningful scenes rather than scenes that are clearly put there just to take up more time. Only thing keeping this movie from getting an "oh no" is Leo, he really was good but not great.
Written May 18, 2013
I do not care what the critics said. I LOVED IT! It is 100% the most beautiful movie I have EVER seen. I have always been a fan of the director's work and "Romeo and Juliet" has always been my favorite movie, but I think this one almost tops it. Everything about it was perfect.
Written May 26, 2013
Movie is great, stars are terrific, especially Leo and Toby BUT THE MUSIC??? Am still in shock. I am trying to reconcile this modern music with the roar of the 'roaring 20's', especially when there was so much fabulous classics to choose from. For instance, Cole Porter, Duke Ellington, Count Basie, etc., etc., etc. Why 'o' why did they choose to spoil what could have been a 5 star film? The cinematography was great and probably spoiled with the use of 3D. I did not choose to view in 3 D format. This is not a film for very young children as they would never have understood it. However, it would be good for high school kids to see especially if they had read the book and/or other Fitzgerald works. A great American writer of an early era and who probably put a little of his own biography into the writing. Great film for young and old adults. I think it stayed true to Fitzgerald's writing, although I must admit it has been a few years since I read it. Must re-read.
Written May 30, 2013
Wonderful acting, and the combination of classic music with contemporary was genius... the goal was to create a similar energy that the audience could relate to, and I believe it was accomplished! Visually stunning cinematography, and all while hardly straying from the book. Regardless of what critics or cynical moviegoers may say, this film was beautifully done and Gatsby fans (like myself) and first-timers (my husband) alike will be able to appreciate it, as long as they are prepared for a long film! Go see it!
Written May 14, 2013
I thought the beginning started out like a cartoon animated movie. The second half was better.
Tobey McGuire seemed wrong for his part. I kept thinking he was spiderman and he was going to show up in spidie attire..
For all the money they must have put into the movie I think they could have bought a better looking wig for Daisy.
My daughter brought me to the movie for Mothers Day, that was the best part.