Written September 01, 2014
The movie starts promisingly with a realistic portrayal of Mumbai avoiding the glamorized versions presented by the typical movies. The suspense is held tight till the intermission despite the parallel inner stories. However the director let's the screenplay run a bit loose after the interval with too many deviations from the main story that leaves you yawning at certain points. However Amir, Rani and some of the supporting actors keep the movie alive with their good acting. Overall, a good watch albeit not unforgettable.
Written December 03, 2012
Fantastic performances by Aamir, Nawaazuddin Siddiqui and Rani Mukherjee. A break from the typical song-dance routines...Disciplined and effective screenplay and direction.
Definitely a GO... Almost a must go - if only, the suspense was a little more layered...
Written December 02, 2012
Acting by all three whoswho starcast is great. Usually Kareena has a plastic coat over her acting, but here she has shed that routine. Amir & Rani are spot on .... Great work.
Written July 29, 2014
had hight expectations from Aamir. THis is simple and straight story.. no big suspense thriller..
Written August 31, 2014
The good: The film is replete with good performances, very good screenplay, enthralling screenplay and backgroiund music.
The bad: A could-have-better performance from Aamir. The direction of the film after the pre-climax. The climax. But go watch it to figure if the answer indeed lies within.
My detailed review here: goo.gl/vGM6i