Cute and funny movie worth watching - but read the book AFTER

By plessthanpointohfive
Written October 23, 2016
The book, like most books movies are based on, is way better. The movie could never live up to the book because the book spends a whole lot of time inside Pat's head. And that's actually a good thing. The movie has to deviate from the book in order to capture any of the book's spirit. The movie captured Pat and Tiffany's personalities. Unfortunately, the other characters don't fare so well, especially Nikki, who we get to know real well in the book.The movie does NOT capture the utter devastation Pat's mental illness has wrought on his life. In the book, Pat was in the institution for FOUR YEARS, not 8 months. His mother gets him out because he's showing no improvement, and brings him home to see Dr Patel, who is the best Doc in Philly. Pat THINKS he's only been in the facility of 8 months. The move DOES do a good job of making you like Pat as he tries to make himself a better person, even when he fails. And the actors do their jobs fine.
52 out of 91 found this helpful. Did you?

Not a Chick Flick

By mimisflix
Written February 26, 2017
My husband didn't want to see this movie thinking it was a chick flick. I kept telling him it wasn't. Finally giving in since I always go to the movies he wants to see, he agreed to go. He really liked it. It has appeal to both men an women. Great acting by Bradley Cooper, De Niro, and Jennifer Lawrence. Walked out of the theatre feeling good..
49 out of 74 found this helpful. Did you?


By gildaisey
Written January 24, 2017
SILVER ININGS PLAYBOOK. A great movie and really enjoyed it when my wife and I saw it last week. It was a good reward as a birthday celebration for me.
40 out of 73 found this helpful. Did you?

Silver Lining Playbook

By luigi9
Written February 22, 2017
This movie goes through all the stages of dealing with an adult who has emotional problems. It is a bit difficult to watch in the beginning, especially because it may bring up feelings that one has previously held and/or dealt with. It is very well acted and the resolution seems to be very difficult to reach. The movie held our interest and the resolution satisfied us both.
37 out of 65 found this helpful. Did you?

A little too polished for a sobering subject

By brownbeer
Written November 26, 2012
I love both Bradley Cooper and Jennifer Lawrence and they both do a very nice job in this movie. However, the subject is a serious one and both Cooper and Lawrence are simply too polished and attractive to adequately portray these characters. Second, it comes off as a comedy which it really shouldn't be. I was shocked at times when the audience laughed at scenes that were quite distressing. Nevertheless, as in most Hollywood movies, things tidy up in the end and everyone lives happily ever after. Also great for seeing scenes shot in Philadelphia.
37 out of 71 found this helpful. Did you?