Earlier in the week it was revealed that Rachel McAdams was among the names being considered for the role of Felicia Hardy (aka Black Cat) in Spider-Man 4, which begins production early next year. Since then, a number of different sources have confirmed that Sam Raimi and Co. are indeed looking at several women for the part of Black Cat, who, like Batman's Catwoman, was a sexy cat burglar who bonded with Spider-Man over their shared costumed connection.
Apparently, however, that's not the story they're going with in Spidey 4 – and Felicia Hardy will instead be tied to Peter Parker through her father, who becomes the new head of The Daily Bugle (and a possible villain). Doesn't seem all that inspiring – and it may be different when it finally hits the screen – but first thing's first: who should play Black Cat? Here are my five suggestions …
Megan Fox – I already mentioned Fox in my previous post, but I'll throw her name at this again because I think she'd make for a perfect Black Cat, capable of pulling off the unassuming cute girl next door thing before transforming into a sneaky, sexy, slithering villain in a matter of seconds.
Chances of Her Becoming Black Cat: 30% (she's too obvious)
Eva Green – She sort of dropped off the planet after sizzling up the screen as a Bond girl in Casino Royale, but Spider-Man 4 could be a chance for Eva Green to finally make her big-budgeted return and solidify her blockbuster status. She certainly has the curves and enough black hair to play a character named Black Cat, not to mention the perfect sinister persona. And hey, if you've seen The Golden Compass, you'll know this gal is perfectly capable of flying through the air. Spider-Man will definitely have his hands full.
Chances of Her Becoming Black Cat: 60% (here's hoping they let her audition)
Emily Blunt – You've seen her heat up the screen in films like The Devil Wears Prada, Sunshine Cleaning and Charlie Wilson's War, and she'll soon be starring in the buzzed-about Young Victoria, as well as next year's The Wolfman – but in my opinion it's about time Emily Blunt nabs a role in a big-time superhero movie if only to prove that she's got the chops to become The Next Big Thing. The perfect villainous? I think so.
Chances of Her Becoming Black Cat: 50% (with four upcoming films on her plate, it might be hard to squeeze this one in)
Kristen Bell – She's cute and petite and not all that scary, which is why I think Kristen Bell should be given the chance to finally spread her wings and play something other than "cutesy girlfriend" type. Sure, she'd look good as Peter Parker's new love interest, but in order to embody the perfect villain, you have to become the person they'd least expect. Ya know, like Kristen Bell – who would expect this gal to show up dressed as a Black Cat ready to kick some ass and take names later?
Chances of Her Becoming Black Cat: 70% (if she's willing to go from blonde to brunette, I could definitely see it)
Kristen Stewart – Why not, right? If there's one problem with Stewart, it's that she always plays these angsty, emotionally scarred teenagers who need therapy more than they need a vampire boyfriend. So wouldn't it be great to see her throw on a costume and serve Spider-Man a taste of his own medicine?
Chances of Her Becoming Black Cat: 20% (she'll probably be too busy filming more Twilight movies like Breaking Dawn, which may begin production this summer)
Who would you choose to play Black Cat? Any of my suggestions make sense?
Editor's note: Thanks for pointing out that the character's hair is indeed blonde in the comics. My picks still remain the same, though, except now Kristen Bell is the only one who doesn't have to change her hair color.
Erik is a leading movie commentator who has worked for outlets such as AOL Moviefone and Movies.com.
Special Offer
Take one last trip to Oz with the For Good Collector’s Pack, featuring a Movie Ticket and a Limited-Edition Costume Sketch Poster by Paul Tazewell.exclusive sketch of Academy Award-winning designer Paul Tazewell’s original costume design!
*For Good Collector’s Pack is non-refundable. While supplies last. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Movie ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. The Poster Print will begin shipping in the month of November. Please use a physical address where the item can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. See full terms and conditions at https://redeem.fandango.com/products/for-good-collectors-pack . Universal Pictures Marketing and its affiliates are not sponsors of this bundle.
Love classic films? Love someone who loves classic films? Check out Turner Classic Movies Film Festival exclusive holiday gifting items through Fandango FanStore.
Get the "Pandango Pin Bundle" and receive a Zootopia 2 ticket and an exclusive mystery pin of Nick and Judy, Flash or Gary!
*Pandango Pin Bundle is non-refundable. While supplies last. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Movie ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. The Official Disney Exclusive Collectible Pin will begin shipping in the month of November. Please use a physical U.S. address where the item can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. See https://redeem.fandango.com/products/pandango-pin-bundle for full terms and conditions.
Buy a ticket to Wicked: For Good, get Wicked for $9 on Fandango at Home!
Limited time offer. Log into your account on Fandango.com or the Fandango app and purchase, between 5am PT on 10/8/25 and 11:59pm PT on 12/7/25, at least one movie ticket to ‘Wicked: For Good’. Purchaser will receive a post-purchase email containing 1 Fandango at Home Promotional Code (“Code”) that is good for the purchase (and not the rental) of ‘Wicked’ for $9 in My Offers in your account on http://athome.fandango.com and via participating Fandango at Home apps. You must have, and be logged into, your Fandango account to receive a Code. Fandango is free to join; you must be 18 years of age or older to create a Fandango account. Code expires on (and must be used by) 12/10/25 at 11:59pm PT. Limit one per transaction. You may have to pay taxes additionally. One-time use only. Void where prohibited. If lost or stolen, cannot be replaced. Offer is non-transferable and cannot be combined with any other offer or discount. No cash value, except as required by law. Not for resale; void if sold or exchanged. Offer valid in the U.S. only (excluding U.S. territories and where prohibited by law). You must have a Fandango at Home account to redeem your Code on Fandango at Home. Fandango at Home is free to join; you must be 18 years of age or older to open a Fandango at Home account. Credit card may be required for transactions on fandangoathome.com. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. This offer and redemption of the Code are subject to Fandango Terms and Policies and Privacy Policy at http://www.fandango.com/terms-and-policies.
Buy a ticket between 11/20-11/29 to opening weekend (12/4-12/7) for Kill Bill: The Whole Bloody Affair and be the first to receive a Gogo Yubari Fortnite outfit!
"Movie ticket is non-refundable. Fortnite outfit will be provided on 11/30/25. Limited time offer. While supplies last. Log into your account on Fandango.com or the Fandango app between 12:00am ET on 11/20/25 and 11:59pm PT on 11/29/25 and purchase at least one movie ticket to ‘Kill Bill: The Whole Bloody Affair’ for an opening weekend showtime (showtimes between 12/4/25 and 12/7/25). On 11/30/25, purchaser will receive a post purchase email containing one (1) Fortnite Promotional Code (“Code”) that is good for one (1) Gogo Yubari Fortnite outfit. Code expires, and must be redeemed at https://www.fortnite.com/redeem by, 4:00pm PT on 12/31/25. Code is one time use only. Limit one Code per Fandango account and Fortnite account. You must have, and be logged into, your Fandango account to receive a Code. Fandango is free to join; you must be 18 years of age or older to create a Fandango account. An Epic Games account is required to play Fortnite and redeem a Code. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. This offer is subject to Fandango's terms and policies, at http://www.fandango.com/terms-and-policies. Redemption of the Code is subject to Epic Games’ Terms of Service, at https://legal.epicgames.com/en-US/epicgames/tos.
Grab The Running Man Collectible Pack and receive a movie ticket and an exclusive collectible lenticular card mini-print!
*The Running Man Collectible Pack is non-refundable. While supplies last. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Movie ticket is non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. The Lenticular Card Mini-Print will begin shipping in the month of November. Please use a physical address where the item can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. See full terms and conditions at https://redeem.fandango.com/products/the-running-man-collectible-pack.
Buy tickets to see the film three times in IMAX, get a limited-edition Avatar: Fire and Ash print
Limited time offer. While supplies last. Log into your account on Fandango.com or the Fandango app between 6:00am PT on 11/17/25 and 11:59pm PT on 1/23/26 and purchase at least three (3) IMAX tickets to three (3) different IMAX showtimes of ‘Avatar: Fire and Ash’ (purchases must be made in separate transactions). Purchaser will receive an email on 1/25/26 containing one (1) Promotional Code (“Code”) that is redeemable for one Avatar: Fire and Ash limited-edition IMAX print, while supplies last. Limited-edition print will ship in February. There is a limited quantity of Codes available in this promotion. Codes will stop being distributed on the earlier of (i) the Code distribution limit being reached, (ii) Avatar: Fire and Ash no longer being in theaters, or (iii) 11:59pm PT on 1/26/26. There is a limited quantity of Code redemptions available in this promotion. Code expires, and can no longer be used, when the limit of Code redemptions has been reached, or at 11:59pm PT on 2/1/26, whichever comes first. Limit one Code per transaction. You may have to pay taxes additionally. One-time use only. Void where prohibited. Offer is non-transferable and cannot be combined with any other offer or discount. If lost or stolen, cannot be replaced. No cash value, except as required by law. Non-transferable. Not for resale; void if sold or exchanged. Offer valid in the U.S. only. You must have, and be logged into, your Fandango account to receive a Code. Fandango is free to join; you must be 18 years of age or older to create a Fandango account. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. This offer is subject to Fandango Terms and Policies and Privacy Policy at Terms and Policies at http://www.fandango.com/terms-and-policies.
Embark on a final journey to Pandora with the Collector’s Print Bundle, featuring one Movie Ticket and a Limited-Edition Print!
*Collector’s Print Bundle is non-refundable. Domestic shipping will be added at checkout. Limited time offer. While supplies last. Movie tickets are non-refundable and non-exchangeable. Fandango reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time and without notice. You must be 18 years of age or older to purchase a bundle. The Collectible Mini Print will begin shipping in December. Please use a physical U.S. address where the poster shipment can be delivered. Once carrier confirms delivery, Fandango is not responsible for lost or stolen deliveries. See full terms and conditions at https://redeem.fandango.com/products/collectors-print-bundle.