The Movie Blog

  • RSS

Can We Toast 'Tintin' without the Alcohol?

By: Tara McNamara on December 22, 2011 at 10:15AM Comments (10)
Critics are raising their glasses to the technical marvel of The Adventures of Tintina globe-trotting holiday adventure treat. However, parents should be aware that the family film includes so much alcohol, it might as well be a character in the film.  
The animated adventure quest follows Tintin, a young investigative reporter who is trying to unravel the mystery of a lost ship with the help of a constantly inebriated Captain Haddock. Much like the lovable Captain Jack Sparrow, Haddock is a drunk who is surprisingly nimble, capable, and powerful – who wouldn’t want to start drinking if it meant you could create fuel with your breath? While our hero disapproves of Haddock’s intoxication, the presence, consumption, and mention of liquor occurs more frequently than the word “smurf” in The Smurfs.
Haddock’s alcoholism is straight from the source material, a Belgian comic strip that began in 1929. However, it made me wonder why filmmakers include drunkenness at all in films directed at children and teens? Besides the Pirates of the Caribbean films this year, The Green Hornet is all about a hard-partying rich kid who finds responsibility through irresponsibility and even squeaky-clean Captain America tries to drink away his sorrows in Captain America: The First Avenger.  
Removing smoking from most G, PG and PG-13 movies seems to be making a positive impact in reducing smoking rates in youth. Perhaps Hollywood should next look at reducing the alcohol consumption in kids’ movies as a positive New Year’s resolution in 2012.
Meanwhile, here are some films families can enjoy without a breathalyzer:
Arthur Christmas Christmas is finally here! If you haven’t already seen it, Arthur Christmas is a fun look at how Santa’s global operation functions as well as how his own family dysfunctions (although it’s implied Grand Santa hits the bottle as well. Sigh.)
 
The Muppets The Muppets is a meta-journey with our felt friends that brings mega-smiles. It’s simply one of the most hilarious-yet-appropriate movies of the year.
 
 
Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol The stunts and cinematography are breathtaking and the action so immersive, audiences won’t believe they can feel so much joy while sitting on the edge of their seat. The violence is prolific, but in a heavily choreographed way that comes off no more graphic than what a kid might see on TV.
 
To read what kids think about The Adventures of Tintin, Arthur Christmas, The Muppets, Mission Impossible and other movies, go to www.KidsPickFlicks.com.

Categories: Family Films

Comments (10)Leave a Comment

  • Jan 28th 2012 6:09AM

    1787592931  said...

    I really think the movie shows alcoholism as a problem, not as something funny or enjoyable. It is quite interesting to see this discussion because such questions have never been raised here, in Brazil, about the movie. The general view around here, which I share, is that Captain Haddock's problem is issued as, well, a problem and that the movie focus more on him overcoming it than on any kind of alcohol endorsement. Therefore I can't really see the Captain's alcoholism as a negative issue of the movie.

    Reply

    Characters Remaining: 750
    • E-mail me when someone replies to my comment
  • Jan 11th 2012 9:03AM

    mammamia3  said...

    I think some parents should completely avoid going with their kids to movies, if they're concern/shocked about some alcohol scene ( Tin-Tin or Hugo). They should concentrate their concerns on the HUGE amount of violence their little darlings absorbs every day between wii and xbox game. Have they ever played with their kids one of those violent game?

    Reply

    Characters Remaining: 750
    • E-mail me when someone replies to my comment
  • Jan 11th 2012 9:00AM

    mammamia3  said...

    I think some parents should completely avoid going with their kids to movies, if they're concern/shocked about some alcohol scene ( Tin-Tin or Hugo). They should concentrate their concerns on the HUGE amount of violence their little darlings absorbs every day between wii and xbox game. Have they ever played with their kids one of those violent game?

    Reply

    Characters Remaining: 750
    • E-mail me when someone replies to my comment
  • Dec 31st 2011 10:49AM

    fivekitten  said...

    TinTin gave the message that alcoholism is bad and hard to conquer. I didn't see it glamourizing alcohol at all and was surprised others thought. The movie portrayed the messages that it's hard for an alcoholic to get sober, how stupid you can be when you're drunk, how vulnerable you are, how you lose important things when drinking, there will be relapses, and also that alcoholism can be battled - albeit with difficulty. The idolized character (Tintin) was promoting sobriety. I'm thinking its clear the writers wanted alcoholism portrayed with its difficulties. I'm not liberal with my daughter's movie-viewing, but not as right-winged as others either - but this was DEFINITELY NOT a drinking-promoting storyline.

    Reply

    Characters Remaining: 750
    • E-mail me when someone replies to my comment
  • Dec 28th 2011 10:00AM

    EricMint  said...

    How about we let the movies entertain and the parents do the parenting and teaching. If you think this movie has a negative message about alcohol, don't take your kids. Or better yet take them and talk to them about it afterwards. Why do you want to let movies teach your kids their life lessons?

    Reply

    Characters Remaining: 750
    • E-mail me when someone replies to my comment
  • Dec 27th 2011 12:28PM

    Aearrinn  said...

    What a load of crock. There is a lot of alcohol at the grocery store, too. Does that mean kids arent allowed in or will be tempted to drink becausse of it?! They said the same thing about Harry Potter, and you know what? I doubt one single kid was tempted to become an alcoholic. What about old Mickey cartoons where the bad guy always smokes a cigar? Come on people!! She used rightly it becomes a pleasant part of culture, and kids need to be taught its proper place.

    Reply

    Characters Remaining: 750
    • E-mail me when someone replies to my comment
  • Dec 26th 2011 9:09AM

    majkaos  said...

    Its obvious that none of the above folks that commented have seen the movie, and/or they don't have children themselves and couldn't give a rats ass. They used Captain Haddocks liquor as Popeye uses spinach. Ability to remember things lost forgotten, super strength, etc... "Oh look, the captain got drunk and lit the lifeboat on fire, har-har." Really? I dont believe it will make children go out and drink, but gives kids a false perception of right and wrong, as well as what's funny. Additionally, since this film was marketed for small children, it would imprint them with images they don't quite grasp, but will linger for some time. When trailertrash, I mean trailerfan, saw the alcohol usage in Raiders, it wasnt glamorized as in Tintin.

    Reply

    Characters Remaining: 750
    • E-mail me when someone replies to my comment
  • Dec 26th 2011 7:32AM

    claytonhill  said...

    what a joke. This is an idiotic op piece littered with improper assumptions ( smoking in movies was the cause for kids smoking) and unbalanced comments ( as KnaveRupe points out above). Please tell me you have another real job.

    Reply

    Characters Remaining: 750
    • E-mail me when someone replies to my comment
  • Dec 23rd 2011 5:46AM

    KnaveRupe  said...

    Let's see if I've got this right: Violence in Mission Impossible = ok. Alcohol in Tintin = Helen Lovejoy lamenting "Won't somebody PLEASE think of the children?!" [BLOCKED WEBSITE] Is that a fair summary?

    Reply

    Characters Remaining: 750
    • E-mail me when someone replies to my comment
  • Dec 22nd 2011 12:52PM

    trailerfan  said...

    all i can say is i remember plenty of booze at the beginning of "Raiders" when i was a kid...and i still don't drink...i don't think adventure movies like this one glamorize alcohol consumption...i think movies like "Arthur" might present a bigger issue...

    Reply

    Characters Remaining: 750
    • E-mail me when someone replies to my comment

Fandango Bloggers