Kevin Heffernan as Wade, Wood Harris as Darrell, Paul Schneider as Tommy, Olivia Munn as Audrey, Jude Ciccolella as Coach Stubbs, Nat Faxon as Zig-Zag, Lindsey Kraft as Greta, Constance Zimmer as Mona and Collette Wolfe as Allison in "The Babymakers."