Marrieds at the Movies: 'Gatsby''s Not So Great

Every Friday night, sends cinephiles (and newlyweds) Sarah and Joe Piccirillo to see a film. Afterwards, they answer a few questions about it. Below is their discussion.


The Great Gatsby

Synopsis: In Baz Luhrmann’s adaptation of the classic novel, wide-eyed Nick Carraway (Tobey Maguire) meets the mysterious Jay Gatsby (Leonardo DiCaprio) and becomes drawn into the millionaire’s obsession for his old love, Daisy (Carey Mulligan).

Was this a good date movie?

Joe: If you hated reading classic literature in high school, imagine instead having it performed as a 3-hour musical.

Sarah: Would you consider this a musical?

Joe: I would. It has the lavish productions but without the singing.

Sarah: I don’t even know what the hell this was, let alone whether it was a good date movie.

Joe: Right about the time they introduced us to Daisy and Jordan on a couch obscured by giant gauze while hip-hop played in the background, I wanted to throw things at the screen. So no, not a good date movie.


Was Baz Luhrmann the right person to adapt the novel?

Joe: I think Luhrmann would be better suited to making a screen adaptation of Cirque du Soleil or a pinball machine.

Sarah: I felt like he captured the lavishness and boozed-up frenzy that Nick encounters, but he totally whiffed on themes of the self-made man and the American Dream. In other words, the stuff that makes the book enduring.

Joe: Right. It seems his interpretation of the novel is less about the emptiness of excess and more about, “OMG, Look at those dancing ladies!” and, “Ooh, did you see those pretty flowers?!” I think Luhrmann is Daisy.

Sarah: Yes! By default, the attention to detail is more a celebration of excess than a criticism of it. In an awesomely tone-deaf tie-in, Tiffany is selling a replica of Daisy’s headband for $200K. Why skewer the idle rich when you can be the idle rich?


What drove you nuts?

Sarah: The tedious melodrama. It’s theatrical and not relatable. It drove me bonkers.

Joe: The elaborate and long party sequences. I get it. You like to party.

Sarah: Nick’s voiceovers, which were a dead ringer for Peter Falk in The Princess Bride. Wrong tone.

Joe: When lines from the book were thrown up on screen in full sky-writer mode. If you’re going to commit to a movie, you shouldn’t also read from the book.

Sarah: When the movie blows any suspense about Gatsby’s backstory.

Joe: If you use 3D for a love story – and it’s not porn – what are you doing?

Sarah: There’s no way to avoid the awkwardness of “old sport.”


What will you be thinking about tomorrow?

Sarah: Oh my god the drinks that Nick and Gatsby had at the speakeasy – there were little pearl ice cubes filling the glass, and I can’t wait until the hipster mustache whiskey bars start using them.

Joe: Wait. Are you being sarcastic? I can’t tell.

Sarah: Both. I’m making fun of the bars but I totally want the ice cubes.

Joe: For me, the sanitarium scenes were cool. It’s a great writer’s retreat – you get lodging, breakfast, and notes on your manuscript.

Sarah: Baz Lurhmann thinks that a sanitarium is a fine stand-in for the Midwest. Burn.

Joe: When I read the book, I felt like I was reading a cool, modern story. Watching this, it felt like a movie about an old, washed-up book.



Sarah: I think I would have been nauseous if we’d watched it in 3D. I almost threw up watching it in 2D. Pass.

Joe: You have a sexy way with words. Let’s put it this way: when the only character in the movie you root for is the philandering, racist woman-beater, you’ve made a serious production mistake. Skip it.

Sarah: Now who’s being sexy?


Sarah and Joe are writers/editors who live in Boston. They met in a bar and married within a year. They love to argue about early Woody Allen films and old romantic comedies. They both agree to hate musicals.


Like it? Share it:

Next Article by Sean OConnell

Box Office: 'Gatsby' Posts a Great Number, But 'Iron Man' Still Reigns Supreme

Box Office: 'Gatsby' Posts a Great Number, But 'Iron Man' Still Reigns Supreme

Send Me FanText

Thanks for signing up!

By entering your mobile number and clicking "SIGN ME UP!", you consent to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and authorize Fandango and its service providers to deliver FanTexts and other promotional texts to your mobile phone. Text marketing authorization is not required for any purchase from Fandango. Message and data rates may apply. We will not send more than 5 msgs/month. You can unsubscribe at any time by texting "STOP" or seek help by texting "HELP" to "FNDGO" (36346).