80

Variety

By Justin Chang
Its modesty is what makes its very real virtues -- a tart, literate script, an adroit balance of humor and pathos, a memorable onscreen collaboration between star-scribe Scott Caan and his father James -- so cumulatively impressive.
Full Review
50

Chicago Reader

By J.R. Jones
The end is swollen with macho brooding before the hero finds the inner strength to accept the advances of another incredible dish.
Full Review
50

New York Daily News

By Joe Neumaier
In a certain kind of indie movie, the only thing sweeter than a bad boy transformed is slow, sad tragedy. Mercy has both, which isn't good.
Full Review
50

New York Post

By Lou Lumenick
Despite risible dialogue, Mercy is watchable because of Caan's physical presence -- and a couple of scenes with his real-life father, James Caan, as his cynical dad who pronounces that "love -- it does not exist."
Full Review
50

The New York Times

By Stephen Holden
Had John Cassavetes directed “Love Story,” it might have turned out looking and sounding something like Mercy, a portrait of a sub-Mailer-like literary pugilist and the woman (named Mercy) who wins his heart. Odd as that juxtaposition may seem, it’s not a bad mix.
Full Review
50

Village Voice

At the risk that giving Scott Caan a bad review will cause him to fall in love with me, I must note the irony in a film that seeks to critique superficiality, only to fall back on the old "dead fiancées deepen dipshits" trick.
Full Review
50

Chicago Sun-Times

By Roger Ebert
What's lacking is a little more depth. This is a movie that covers a lot of distance in only 87 minutes.
Full Review
40

Boxoffice Magazine

By John P. McCarthy
Mercy can be described as a moody picture that traffics in variations of only one mood or sentiment: self-pity.
Full Review
40

Time Out New York

By David Fear
Caan can’t seem to play up his strengths. He’s a raw talent who needs an editor for his scripts and a strong hand behind the camera guiding him. Mercy gives our guy neither.
Full Review
40

Los Angeles Times

A romantic drama with some good qualities -- among them earnestness and strong performances -- but not enough to completely overcome the strain of its clichés.
Full Review
46 out of 100
Mixed or average reviews
Metascore® based on all critic reviews. Scores range from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating more favorable reviews.