80 New Times (L.A.) | Gregory Weinkauf Maybe Baby is Elton's stab at romantic comedy, and it's a strong feature debut, spiffy, quick-witted and more than a little shocking in its unflinching acknowledgement of English people having sex. Read full review
70 L.A. Weekly | Chuck Wilson A film we hereby proclaim the finest fertility comedy ever made, in the faint hope that another will not be attempted. Read full review
70 The New York Times | Stephen Holden A juggling act between high soap opera and low comedy, Maybe Baby manages to keep its pins in the air until very near the end. Read full review
60 TV Guide | Maitland McDonagh Atkinson's painfully unfunny turn as an insensitive gynecologist is eclipsed by Hollander's scathingly funny portrayal of belligerent auteur Proclaimer, whose wears his pretenses with such scabby aplomb that they achieve high style. Read full review