The movie was very good, and very true to the books. I actually liked the high frame rate everything had a realistic look except for a few of the made for 3D effects. Butterfly's come to mind. The abrupt ending left you wanting more. I didn't really care for the rock monsters rock fight and the incident with the trolls wasn't as I remembered it. I really enjoyed everything else, I may watch it again in 2D just to see the differences.