75 Chicago Tribune | Michael Phillips The performances and Marcos Siega’s direction put a pleasing sheen on the material. Read full review
75 San Francisco Chronicle | Ruthe Stein By creating likable characters and putting them in situations that seem plausible, if a bit of a stretch, the film succeeds where others of its genre fail. Read full review
63 Boston Globe | Ty Burr "Maybe" was watchable and blandly pleasant; "Theory" is a smidgen better than that, if not the cruelly funny farce the movie's best impulses and its own trailer would have you believe. Read full review
63 The Globe and Mail (Toronto) | Liam Lacey When you watch Canadian actor Ryan Reynolds, there's often a sense that you're not just watching him perform in a movie, you're watching the next stage of his unfolding career plan. Read full review