Joe Cartwright joins a posse led by Sheriff Rimbau (John Ireland) to capture two robbery/murder suspects. For Rimbau, it is personal: His own brother Jack (James B. Sikking) was killed by the outlaws. Before long, Joe realizes that Rimbau intends to be judge, jury and executioner, thoroughly prepared to cold-bloodedly murder two men who may well be innocent. John Ford regular Harry Carey Jr. appears as Mapes. Originally telecast on February 26, 1967, "Judgement at Red Creek" was written by Robert Sabaroff. ~ Hal Erickson, Rovi