Despite her trepidations that Tabitha may try out her witchcraft on strangers, Samantha enrolls her daughter in nursery school. Though Tabitha tries to rein in her powers, the jig is up when her classmate, Amy (Maralee Foster), refusing to imitate a toad in a school play, insists she'd rather be a butterfly. Veteran character actress Maudie Prickett appears as long-suffering teacher Mrs. Burch. Written by Douglas Tibbles, "I Don't Want to Be a Toad" originally aired on December 21, 1968. ~ Hal Erickson, Rovi