The Hollywood Reporter

By Stephen Farber
Sparkling dialogue would count for little without two actors to deliver it expertly. Garcia (who is also one of the producers of the film) is generally cast in more serious roles, but he revealed a gift for comedy in "City Island" a few years ago, and he revisits that terrain rewardingly here. Farmiga is marvelous.
Full Review

San Francisco Chronicle

By Mick LaSalle
It's a lovely film that grows along with the characters. At first, it seems like a pleasing but inconsequential comedy. But it deepens as their connection deepens and opens up into a place of poignancy and insight.
Full Review

New York Observer

By Rex Reed
Entertaining dialogue and a collection of tightly knit performances — especially a wonderful, unexpectedly funny star turn by Andy Garcia — make At Middleton a nice surprise.
Full Review

Chicago Tribune

By Michael Phillips
Small as it is, the film itself functions as a catchy, bittersweet waltz. You've heard it before, but the dancers are fun to watch.
Full Review


By Ella Taylor
Though it's fun to watch Garcia let out his inner goofball, the jewels in the crown of At Middleton are the dynamic sisters Farmiga.
Full Review

Chicago Sun-Times

By Mary Houlihan
At Middleton is an innocuous romantic comedy.
Full Review

Arizona Republic

By Bill Goodykoontz
At Middleton is an almost completely inauthentic little romance that is so genuinely pleasant you’ll enjoy it anyway.
Full Review

The Dissolve

By Scott Tobias
Farmiga and Garcia have a chemistry that’s unassuming and sneaky, and the pleasure they get from each other’s company ultimately proves infectious.
Full Review

The A.V. Club

By Ignatiy Vishnevetsky
Unremarkable, though hardly unpleasant, the middlebrow middle-age romance At Middleton often plays like a forgotten trifle from the Golden Age of Hollywood studio filmmaking, distinguished more by its competence and affable performances than by any formal or thematic potency.
Full Review

Village Voice

By Michael Nordine
Farmiga and Garcia give it their all, and their chemistry keeps certain scenes afloat.
Full Review
60 out of 100
Generally favorable reviews
Metascore® based on all critic reviews. Scores range from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating more favorable reviews.