Small-town garage mechanic Aaron Menefee (Andrew Prine) becomes a devoted disciple of the Reverend Otis Jones (Sidney Blackmer) after the traveling faith healer seemingly cures Menefee's ulcer. Even so, Jones refuses Menefee permission to marry his daughter Emily (Maggie Pierce), arguing that Aaron's faith isn't "strong enough." Thus does Menefee challenge himself with the ultimate test of that faith -- leading to a memorable "Lady or the Tiger" denouement. ~ Hal Erickson, Rovi